How to Improve Gym Retention by Adding Revenue Layers with Connor from Code 5

In this week’s episode of Profit Made Simple, I welcomed back Connor from Code 5 for his 2nd appearance on the show. Every time he joins us, he brings practical strategies that are battle tested in real fitness businesses.

Today’s conversation centred around vertical integration, which is the process of stacking additional products, services, and revenue streams inside your gym.

Not only does this grow your bottom line, but it is also one of the most effective ways of improving gym retention. Members who use more services stay longer, spend more, and feel more connected to your community.

This episode is packed with actionable insights, real numbers, mistakes to avoid, and examples of layered services that are currently working inside Code 5.

Here is everything we covered:

Why Vertical Integration Matters for Gym Owners

There are two major reasons you should be thinking about adding layers to your fitness business.

  1. Members who use more products stay longer.
    Just like banks who keep customers longer when they hold multiple products, gyms experience improved retention when members use secondary services. The more they engage, the longer they stick around.
  2. It improves profit during an expensive era to run gyms.
    Rent is rising. Staffing costs are rising. Members expect more than ever. Additional revenue layers help you stabilise profit without needing hundreds of new members.

But layering services is not without risk. The biggest danger is diluted focus. Multiple products require multiple champions. They need oversight, marketing, and consistency. This is why you must approach new services carefully.

How to Know When You Should Add a New Service

Connor’s simple rule is to look at what your clients are already paying for outside your gym. If your members pay someone else for it and you could deliver it in house at the same or higher standard, that is a sign of opportunity.

However, he also stressed that this is not an invitation to rush in blindly. You must build the foundations first, grow a solid membership base, and ensure that your core product is working before you stack new layers on top.

Lessons from Failed Attempts

Connor shared openly about one of his early attempts at adding massage as a service. It failed because of under investment. The room was not soundproof enough. The experience was not premium enough. The therapist was not a perfect fit. The marketing oversold the service. Members used it initially because they loved the gym, but the experience was not strong enough to keep them coming back.

His takeaway was clear. Half effort creates half results. If you introduce a new service, you must invest properly in environment, team, equipment, and experience.

Retreats The First Big Success Layer

Retreats are one of Code 5’s signature revenue layers and have been running successfully for almost a decade. Connor explained that retreats were a natural fit because they solved a real member problem.

Members would go on holidays, drink heavily, eat poorly, return feeling flat, and regain weight. Connor created a retreat that offered a healthier reset, a memorable experience, and an environment where members could still enjoy themselves while returning home feeling good.

Retreats worked because they checked every box.

  • They were fun and aligned with the brand
  • They helped retention
  • They provided lifestyle transformation
  • They generated meaningful revenue
  • They built stronger relationships
  • They allowed Connor to deliver impact in a deeper way

He prices retreats by covering costs, adding a margin, and ensuring members understand what is included. The financial aim is a 10 to 15 percent profit margin while delivering an unforgettable experience.

What Makes Code 5 Retreats Unique

Connor intentionally designs retreats to push people out of their comfort zones and bond quickly. These experiences include team-based challenges, unusual activities like beer miles, Amazing Race style competitions, strength and yoga sessions, and shared meals to encourage social mixing.

This engineered connection is why members return year after year. It strengthens community and improves long term retention.

Endurance Coaching a Strong Subscription Layer

Another highly successful layer is endurance coaching. Code 5 noticed members were training for half marathons and marathons, but they were outsourcing coaching to outside providers. Many even left the gym entirely to join endurance communities.

To solve this, they brought endurance coaching in house. Members now receive:

  • Running programming
  • Strength sessions
  • Progress reviews
  • Access to an expert coach
  • Community events like Noosa Marathon and Queenstown Marathon

This added layer keeps members inside the ecosystem and gives them a long-term pathway after they lose weight or reach initial goals. It is an additional subscription, and it is rapidly growing.

Code Hot Adding Infrared Yoga and Pilates

One of Code 5’s newest layers is hot yoga and Pilates. This decision was driven by member polling, trend analysis, and competitive mapping. There were no infrared studios in the immediate area, which presented a gap in the market.

The result has been strong demand, improved retention, and powerful cross pollination. Members trial Code Hot, then upgrade to access the main gym. Others join the gym and add Code Hot for recovery and mobility.

It also creates new marketing angles, new audiences, and new lead generation funnels.

Polling Members the Most Underrated Skill in Fitness Business

One theme came up repeatedly. Ask your members. Ask your database. Ask your audience. Gym owners often assume they know what people want, but the data tells the truth.

Before investing in a new layer like recovery or supplements, Connor checks three things:

  1. Do members want it
  2. Do the numbers stack up
  3. What is the local competition doing

Simple. Effective. Reliable.

Weight Loss Coaching One of the Easiest Wins

Accountability based nutrition coaching is one of Code 5’s most profitable and impactful layers. Members pay for structure and accountability. When people pay, they pay attention.

Coaches with basic nutritional qualifications run 12 and 26 week programs focused on habits, lifestyle, and consistency. This consistently delivers powerful results and deeper member loyalty.

For gym owners, this is often the easiest and highest return layer to add.

Supplements The Next Layer Coming Soon

Connor is close to launching Success Supplements, a subscription-based system designed to integrate into gyms. Members receive monthly supplement boxes delivered to the gym, which creates excitement and visibility.

The goal is to help gym owners add an extra ten thousand dollars a year in recurring profit with minimal time investment.

Final Thoughts for Fitness Business Owners

Vertical integration is no longer optional. It is essential. With rising costs, competitive markets, and shifting member expectations, revenue layers help you stay profitable and improve retention.

Start simple. Add one layer. Make it exceptional. Listen to your members. Make decisions with data. And ensure every new layer improves both member outcomes and member stickiness.